Aldermen approve city police review board
By Kevin Lavery & Tom Weber, KWMU
St. Louis, MO – St. Louis aldermen approved the creation of a civilian review board for the city police department Friday. The vote was 17-12.
The legislation has stalled in past aldermanic sessions.
One controversy had been whether review board members should be elected or appointed.
The version that passed would have the mayor pick board members from a list of candidates that alderman submitted. The mayor's choices would then go back to aldermen for final approval.
Ald. Terry Kennedy (Ward 18) is the sponsor of the legislation.
But Ald. Stephan Gregali (Ward 14) had told the Post-Dispatch he planned to filibuster, saying the city's police board already acts as a civilian review board.
But when the bill came up for debate, Ald. Gregory Carter (Ward 27) called for a vote before Gregali could address aldermen. That procedure shut down debate.
The police board created its own civilian review board nearly two years ago, but Mayor Francis Slay hasn't appointed anyone to it because of the controversy.
Slay said he will not sign the legislation because some of its wording is offensive to police.
"I will not sign a bill that has this type of inflammatory, anti-police language in it," Slay said.
The bill's preamble says "A blue wall of silence persists among some officers throughout this country and in the City of St. Louis hindering fair internal investigations and raising questions whether officers themselves should be the only ones or the only level of investigation and leaving litigation as the main recourse for citizens not confident in a mostly internal system..."
STL Civilian Review Board
|St. Louis Aldermen voting YES|
|Jim Shrewsbury (Board President)|
|Charles Quincy Troupe (Ward 1)|
|Dionne Flowers (Ward 2)|
|Freeman M. Bosley, Sr. (Ward 3)|
|O.L. Shelton (Ward 4)|
|April Ford-Griffin (Ward 5)|
|Lewis E. Reed (Ward 6)|
|Phyllis Young (Ward 7)|
|Jennifer Florida (Ward 15)|
|Joseph D. Roddy (Ward 17)|
|Terry Kennedy (Ward 18)|
|Michael McMillan (Ward 19)|
|Craig Schmid (Ward 20)|
|Bennice Jones King (Ward 21)|
|Jeffrey Boyd (Ward 22)|
|Frank Williamson (Ward 26)|
|Gregory Carter (Ward 27)|
|St. Louis Aldermen voting NO|
|Stephen Conway (Ward 8)|
|Kenneth Ortmann (Ward 9)|
|Joseph Vollmer (Ward 10)|
|Matt Villa (Ward 11)|
|Fred Heitert (Ward 12)|
|Fred Wessels (Ward 13)|
|Stephen Gregali (Ward 14)|
|Donna Baringer (Ward 16)|
|Kathleen Hanrahan (Ward 23)|
|William Waterhouse (Ward 24)|
|Dorothy Kirner (Ward 25)|
|Lyda Krewson (Ward 28)|