Zurich Chess Challenge
12:07 am
Thu February 6, 2014

On Chess: Nakamura Misses Chance to Topple World Champion

He came close this time. The great white whale was in his sights. His elbow was cocked, and in his hand the harpoon was ready to deliver the fatal blow. And then it all disappeared.

Hikaru Nakamura last battled Magnus Carlsen at the Sinquefield Cup in St. Louis. Levon Aronian observes.
Hikaru Nakamura last battled Magnus Carlsen at the Sinquefield Cup in St. Louis. Levon Aronian observes.
Credit Chess Club and Scholastic Center of St. Louis

Over the weekend, St. Louisan and U.S. No. 1 Hikaru Nakamura let slip his first-ever victory against the reigning World Champion, Magnus Carlsen. Nakamura quickly went from a winning position to completely lost in round three of the recently concluded Zurich Chess Challenge 2014. (Click here to see a full report and analysis of the game.)

In the 23 classical games the two have played against one another, Nakamura has never beaten Carlsen, losing eight times and drawing 15. This was, almost certainly, the closest Nakamura has come to scoring that elusive first victory against the No. 1 player in the world.

In chess, the slightest misstep can completely change the outcome of a game.  When you’re playing the World Champion, a win can turn into a loss in an instant. And that loss can be the defining point of the tournament.

The Zurich Chess Challenge laid claim to the strongest chess tournament in history, topping even the Sinquefield Cup, which was held in St. Louis this past September.  In addition to Nakamura and Carlsen, the field was made up of World No. 2 Levon Aronian, Fabiano Caruana, Viswanathan Anand and Boris Gelfand.

Aronian followed his recent victory in Wijk aan Zee with another solid showing in Zurich. He is playing some of the best chess of his career right now, and he is the odds-on favorite in the upcoming Candidates’ tournament, which will take place next month in Khanty-Mansiysk, Russia. The winner of that event earns the right to challenge Carlsen for the World Championship.

Nakamura did not earn an invite to the Candidates’ this year, so he’ll have to be content with improving his consistency and fine-tuning his game for the time being.

In a recent article in New in Chess magazine, Nakamura is quoted as stating he views himself as the biggest threat to Carlsen at the moment. At a press conference following his victory in Zurich, Carlsen initially brushed off the claim, joking that the guy sitting next to him [Aronian] was playing pretty well as of late.

But that doesn’t mean Carlsen hasn’t taken notice of Nakamura’s dynamic play.

“Hikaru has his opinions about his strength, my strength; I have mine,” Carslen said. “But to be fair, he outplayed me in classical chess this time, so there might be something to it. I don’t know.”

Nakamura has demonstrated steady improvement and asserted himself as one of the most dangerous players on the planet. Carlsen admitted that he got lucky to survive this time.

While not everyone in the chess world might agree with Nakamura’s assessment that he’s Carlsen’s biggest threat currently, there’s certainly no denying that if he continues on his current trajectory he will one day be a viable challenger to throne.

Note: Mike Wilmering is a 2006 graduate of the University of Missouri at Columbia School of Journalism and serves as the communications specialist for the Chess Club and Scholastic Center of St. Louis.