Missouri Executes Earl Ringo, Eighth Inmate Of The Year
No state has carried out more executions than Missouri this year. Early this morning, Missouri carried out its eighth execution of 2014.
Earl Ringo was put to death for killing two people during a robbery that went bad in Columbia.
"Ringo was convicted of the murders of Dennis Poyser and Joanna Baysinger during the robbery of a restaurant in Columbia," Gov. Jay Nixon said in a statement denying clemency. "Both were shot to death brutally, without mercy. The evidence that was presented at trial left no doubt about Ringo’s guilt."
Ringo's lawyers had asked for his execution to be halted, citing new information made public by a St. Louis Public Radio investigation. Last week, our report detailed how Missouri has been using the controversial drug midazolam, in spite of assurances by corrections officials that they would not use the drug. Midazolam, a sedative, was used in several botched executions this year.
Federal courts declined to halt the execution, but Missouri was criticized for its actions in an appeals court dissent.
"The unusually large doses of midazolam Missouri has intravenously injected into inmates in its last four executions – just minutes prior to the time when the death warrants become effective – is alarming with respect to the constitutional prohibition against executing a prisoner in a state of incompetency," Judge Kermit Bye of the Eighth Circuit wrote. He was joined by two other judges.
As we reported last week, experts say the doses Missouri has used would likely put the inmate to a very deep sleep, to the point where breathing could become obstructed. Lawyers representing death row inmates argue it also masks the pain their clients would be feeling.
The Department of Corrections says that it did not inject Ringo with midazolam.
The state contends that midazolam is not part of its execution process but concedes that it is injected at the discretion of the execution team sometimes minutes before Missouri's lethal drug: pentobarbital.
"Missouri has taken great pains to distance itself from the use of midazolam during executions, but without plausibly explaining how administering large doses of the drug just minutes before a death warrant takes effect is meaningfully different from using the controversial drug as part of its actual execution protocol," Bye wrote.
The judge went on to say in his dissent that the amounts and timing of the injection amounted to a de facto use of the drug as part of its protocol.
A divided U.S. Supreme Court voted against halting the execution, although Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Stephen Breyer, Sonia Sotomayor, and Elena Kagan voted to grant the stay.
“It should not be lost in the national debate over the death penalty that Earl Ringo, Jr., was responsible for the murders of two innocent Missourians," Attorney General Chris Koster said in a statement. "For 16 years he avoided payment for this crime. Tonight he has paid the penalty.”
Read our full investigation into the use of midazolam here.
Follow Chris McDaniel on Twitter: @csmcdaniel